who is the better rookie Reggie Bush or Vince Young?

Question

I say Reggie Bush because Reggie took a team who was 3-13 to a NFC Champion contender wow. Vince did nothing except that 62 yard run You tell me

Answer 1

Bush! Vince is a younger Vick!

Answer 2

Wow.........you have some major brain damage if you think Bush took that team to the playoffs. That's a major insult to Drew Brees (who realistically carried them this way). There's also Deuce, and Colston and Horn and their O and D lines.



Who's on the Titans besides Vince? That's right - no one the average fan can name. Vince nearly took that team to the playoffs. Reggie didn't become very explosive till the last 1/3 of the season.



I am a 619er tho so I'd like to believe at the end of their careers Reggie will have had developed into his full potential (basically playing almost as good as he did in college on this level) For now Vince is better (especially since you said rookie --just this year).

Answer 3

Reggie Bush didn't do a whole lot to help the team. He's not even the sole running back, sharing responsibilities with Deuce McAllister. Vince Young took a floundering Tennessee team, and single handedly got them to playoff contention. Vince Young is by far the better of the two this season. Now if Reggie Bush ends up with the starting job, he may have a shot at upturning Young next year.

Answer 4

The Titans were a different team after Vince took over....I love what Bush did for the Saints but the QB position is much tougher and there was no Deuce McAlister to take some of the pressure off for Vince...The QB has to know what every player on the offense is going to do but the RB concentrates on his own assignment.



I'd have to go with Vince for AFC rookie and Bush for NFC...I have to say that what Vince did was far more impressive!

Answer 5

Obvioulsy Vince Young, the Titans didn't have as much talent around Vince as the Saints did around Reggie. Reggie didn't take all the snaps either, Deuce had a better year

Answer 6

Vince Young

Answer 7

As of this year Vince Young for the future Reggie Bush no doubt.

Answer 8

i actually do. i presumed they the place loopy in the previous each thing, yet with the addition of Shaub, and Mario Williams, i actually think of they are better off. Shaub is gonna be a large time NFL QB IMO. Vince is solid, and a Houston community, yet he has flaws little question. i think of Bush is gonna become a large sadness interior the NFL. Out of faculty they the place calling him the perfect considering that Barry Sanders, yet i'm not seeing it. i will see the Texans signing Shaun Alexander, which i think of is a solid %. up. And draft a RB this year. The RB classification is deep this year. i think of the Texans shore up the shielding secondary, and have a lots better season next year. they are purely in a killer branch. i actually think of the Texans front workplace come out smelling like a rose in this deal whilst it fairly is all stated and executed.

Answer 9

I completely agree with Andy T. Bush did bring the team hope. And as a rookie starter he showed great skill. But he was not rookie of the year material this year.Vince Young definatly showed more skill. In my opinion, however, if Marquis Colston of the Saints was not to get injured he would have ran away with rookie of the year. Pretty good for being picked in the last round huh?

Answer 10

I say reggie bush. he is gonna be a great player to come in the next yrs, and should have a outstanding nfl career. I think young is another micheal vick. he will be good as long as his legs hold up.

Answer 11

I think that whitin 5 years Vince Young is going to be the highest paid player in the NFL... Vince Young Rookie of the year.

Answer 12

Reggie Bush ..hands down.

Answer 13

i jus wish that everybody will throw out the stats books and look at what they done. sure reggie bush had ended the year strong but the saints had alot other fire power. vince young almost led his team to a playoff birth after a 0-5 start. look at what he did. he led them back against the giants, and beat the texans in overtime. his season did come short against the great PATRIOTS. GO PATS!!!!

Answer 14

Statiscally and performance wise in the 2007 season young was ,wich i think he deserved rookie of year but longterm bush will stand out on top,texans made huge mistake for not taking him if you ask me

Answer 15

VY all the way baby reggie bush can go to the hot place

Answer 16

This is tough because they were both instrumental in turning their team's season around.



If I have to choose, I agree with you.



Bush helped his team to the playoffs and maybe to the Super Bowl.



GEAUX SAINTS

GEAUX REGGIE

Answer 17

well both are good. however, reggie bush isnt the sole reason that the saints are so much better than last year. drew brees, sean payton (NFL coach of the year). and dont forget devin hester as a great rookie!!

Answer 18

reggie boy

but vince aint half bad

Answer 19

first of all reggie bush didn't take the team nowhere it was drew brees, marques Colston and Deuce and they both play different positions so who cares

Answer 20

I pick Bush too im looking at the wins and hes way cuter

Answer 21

that a tough one i go with bush but Young get credit for improving that team

Answer 22

vince young is better.. saints will lose to the bears

Answer 23

reggie. but it wasn't only reggie who took the team, deuce, sean payton, drew brees, joe horn, marques colston, etc...

Answer 24

u comparing a running back and a quarterback? that's like comparing john elway to jim brown.

Answer 25

reggie casuse he is gonna be like l.t. :)