Top 50 quarterbacks of all time?

Question

I just read this article about a guy who used some equation to create the top 50 qb's of all time. Heres the top 10 from that article just curious what others think

1. Joe Montana
2. Peyton Manning
3. Otto Graham
4. Brett Favre
5. Tom Brady
6. Johnny Unitas
7. John Elway
8. Terry Bradshaw
9. Dan Marino
10. Steve Young

Heres a link to the article and the top 50, its really good i recomend reading it

http://armchairgm.wikia.com/Article:Top_50_Quarterbacks_of_All-Time

Answer 1

I think that list needs to be queaked just a little bit...but the major flaw is putting Tom Brady above Elway and Marino.

Answer 2

Top 50 Quarterbacks Of All Time

Answer 3

Peyton Manning and Tom Brady are still active in the NFL. Then there are the up and comings, Ben Roethlisberger, Philip Rivers, Eli Manning who still have several more years to play. There are others, but these are the three from the same recruiting class. I may have Brett Favre in the top ten, but not the top five. His career remains a guess. Dan Marino belongs at number two, maybe three, but certainly not number nine. I would not put much credence into whatever hyped up equation he used.

Answer 4

I place Elway above Montana and my reason is: Montana had Bill Walsh and Elway had Reeves( for most of his career). If you put Elway under Bill Walsh and the 49ers Elway walks away with one for the thumb. If you put Montana under Reeves and the broncos im not sure Montana even makes a super bowl appearance at all. He definitely wouldn't have gone to 3 SB under Reeves like Elway did. Elway played in 5 SB, 2 SB victories, SB MVP and 9 times voted to the pro bowl. To rank #7 at #7 is a joke. Elway did a lot more with a lot less help around him.

Answer 5

Otto Graham is the greatest of all time



Brett Favre isn't in the top 10

Answer 6

1.Marino- Stats don't lie

2.Johnny Unitas

3.Steve young

4.Dan Fouts

5.Otto Graham

6.John Elway

7.Brett Farve- Though he is a media whore

8.Joe Montana

9.Peyton Manning

10.Roger Staubach

Answer 7

If Brady is #5, that list isn't worth wiping with. No Staubach in the top 5- LOL!

Answer 8

that's a pretty good choice but i think you should put brett favre up at 3rd

Answer 9

Your link be stupid and people on here not be too bright. There can only be one even considered for number one and that be my boy Michael.

Answer 10

peyton needs to mover his *** down and up elway, young, and tarkantin